by Shwoo on Thu Sep 02, 2010 1:23 pm
I voted "It's nice, but it needs work".
I did lurk a bit before I joined, and I have some criticisms:
-Four boards for video games seems a bit over the top for a forum about a Disney cartoon. I don't think there's an above average amount of crossover between gamers and Phineas and Ferb fans.
-I see a fan creations forum, a character discussion forum and an episode discussion forum, but no general Phineas and Ferb discussion forum. I guess they could go in the general misc forum, and I see that they do, but it seems confusing to have them crowded in with the off-topic threads. I really think the forum would benefit from having less restricted Phineas and Ferb discussions.
Telltale Games' Sam & Max subforum is the only one I'm active in, so I'll list the topics of some multipage threads from there that wouldn't be possible here:
Discussion of the time paradox in the ending
Sadness about a character's death
Speculation on a character's motives
Favourite quotes
The "I Find Noir Sam Sexy" Support Group (That one's... not for everyone)
Favourite episode
Least favourite episode
Voice acting discussion
I realise that some of these don't apply to Phineas and Ferb, but the general idea does. And some of them could go in the character discussion topics, but generally those topics can only sustain one discussion at a time before the others get buried.
Actually, I just had the two criticisms. It's just my opinions, and what works in my experience, it's not a demand.
» FanFiction
» Phineas and Ferb: Across the 2nd Dimension
» (Fic) Snow Dungeon
» Perry/Doofenshmirtz
» Candace Disconnected
» Where did everybody go?
» Spongebob ?!?
» Just A Quick Question